This got me thinking.
Specifically, it got me thinking how important this really is.
The founding authors and teachers of modern Paganism are important and I dare say that they always will be. It is also important to be mindful of our roots and to not forget where we have come from. But we also need to be realistic about the degree of relevance that they have.
That is not to suggest that they are no longer relevant, but I believe that we have to accept that the shape of our modern world presents many issues that are just not addressed by those who were writing and teaching half a century ago.
The world – and even Paganism, is not the same as it was for writers and teachers who were experience the world and Paganism in the years from the 1950’s to the 1980’s. Even those years from the 1980’s to 2000 were distinct enough to warrant an extended approach to the young people of that time. These were the “teen witch” years. But Millennials are again in need of something more. While the ideas of yesterday are still important, we need Paganism to expand so that it is relevant to the current shape of the world. While so many of us are looking back, either to the works of the modern founding teachers and writers, or even further back to historical Paganism, we need to also be looking forwards and understanding how those things are relevant to the Paganism of now – and if there are aspects of our modern world that are not addressed by these things, then we need to be willing to explore those things and find how they fit with being Pagan now. Perhaps more importantly, we need to also be willing to throw out those ideas that no longer serve us.
There are also other issues that are far from new and that have been present in Paganism for some time, such as ecology, environmentalism, sacred sites, ancient graves and so on. These kinds of issues also need to be addressed in their modern context, using our best modern understanding, rather than leaving people to form a spiritual perspective on these things using information and ideas that may now be 30+ years out of date.
Of course, some things never change (or change little). The general concept of Nature = Good, is as relevant today as it ever has been, for example. But that is not to say that we wouldn’t benefit from exploring those things with fresh eyes, as well. After all, even the general idea of being pro nature, has it’s limits. For example, I don’t think that any sane Pagan would suggest that we should avoid modern medicine because diseases are natural. In fact, the relationship between nature and human ingenuity is a good subject of discussion. But in this instance, the point is that in the modern day, in the light of growing understanding and technology, even the simplest of Pagan concepts can be expanded upon to make them more relevant to now.
In reality, I doubt that there would be a massive division of views among the majority of Pagans. But there may be a wide variety to approaching these things in regards to Pagan practice and spiritual experience – and that is perhaps more important than anything else. It is one thing to say “oh yeah, we’re cool with homosexuality”, but it is a whole other thing to present ways to explore homosexuality from a spiritual perspecive, in a way that is as indepth as the ways in which hetrosexuality are explored, for example.
This, I feel, is not only important for the developing future of Paganism, but also for giving young people real options for exploring their spirituality in a way that is relevant and present, rather than archaic and incomplete.